Quote
"There are... masterpieces of... exposition... Two examples... are Weils Number Theory for Beginners... and Artins . Mathematics can be done scrupulously."
"Under the same assumptions made in the Chord papers, the [SIGCOMM] version of the protocol is not correct, and not one of the properties claimed invariant in [PODC] is actually invariantly true of it."

A mathematical proof is a deductive argument for a mathematical statement, showing that the stated assumptions logically guarantee the conclusion. The argument may use other previously established statements, such as theorems; but every proof can, in principle, be constructed using only certain basic or original assumptions known as axioms, along with the accepted rules of inference. Proofs are ex
"There are... masterpieces of... exposition... Two examples... are Weils Number Theory for Beginners... and Artins . Mathematics can be done scrupulously."
"A proof of a mathematical theorem is a sequence of steps which leads to the desired conclusion. The rules to be followed... were made explicit when logic was formalized early in the this century... These rules can be used to disprove a putative proof by spotting logical errors; they cannot, however, be used to find the missing proof of a... conjecture. ... arguments are a common occurrence in the practice of mathematics. However... The role of heuristic arguments has not been acknowledged in the philosophy of mathematics despite the crucial role they play in mathematical discovery. ...Our purpose is to bring out some of the features of mathematical thinking which are concealed beneath the apparent mechanics of proof."
"Proofs have gaps and are... inherently incomplete and sometimes wrong. ...There is another reason ...Humans err. ...and others do not necessarily notice our mistakes. ...This suggests an important reason why "more elementary" proofs are better... The more elementary... the easier it is to check, and the more reliable its verification."
"are expressed using no numbers or other symbolic formalisms. Though the nitty-gritty details of the proof are formidably technical, the proofs overall strategy, delightfully, is not. ...They belong to a branch of mathematics known as formal logic or mathematical logic, a field which was viewed, prior to Gödels achievement, as mathematically suspect."
"Perhaps we should discard the myth that mathematics is a rigorously deductive enterprise... hand-waving is intrinsic. We try to minimize it and we can sometimes escape it, but not always, if we want to discover new theorems."
"Proofs are for the mathematician what experimental procedures are for the experimental scientist: in studying them one learns of new ideas, new concepts, new strategies—devices which can be assimilated for ones own research and be further developed."