Quote#Politics & Power
Decisions in the American Courts are entitled to great respect, but…
Quote byArthur Kekewich · 1832–1907
Commonly attributed — not confirmed in an authoritative edition. Cited on Wikiquote to: In re De Nicols. De Nicols v. Curlieb (1898), L. R. 1 C. D. [1898], p. 410..
English (original)
Decisions in the American Courts are entitled to great respect, but are not binding here; and there are many circumstances affecting questions arising between the laws of different States which may or may not be applicable to questions arising here.
— Arthur Kekewich
More from Arthur Kekewich
It is the right of her Majesty's subjects to make claims and to have them tried in the constitutional way.
This seems to me to be one of those cases in which the Court is bound to arrive at a conclusion without having any satisfactory means of arriving at it. The only guide I have is this. I am entitled to sit in the testator's chair as he …
Public policy does not admit of definition and is not easily explained. It is a variable quantity; it must vary and does vary with the habits, capacities, and opportunities of the public.
I think that the proper and safe course is to follow a decision of a Court of co-ordinate jurisdiction, unless some cogent reason is given to the contrary.
It is to my mind much to be regretted, and it is a regret which I believe every Judge on the bench shares, that text-books are more and more quoted in Court—I mean, of course, text-books by living authors—and some Judges have gone so far …
Motives do not concern me; they are a dangerous subject with which to deal.