Quote#Politics & Power
To my mind when a great Judge, a master of the whole subject,…
Quote byWilliam Brett, 1st Viscount Esher · 1815–1899
Commonly attributed — not confirmed in an authoritative edition. Cited on Wikiquote to: Ex parte Bell Cox (1887), 57 L. J. (N. S.) Q. B. 103..
English (original)
To my mind when a great Judge, a master of the whole subject, thinking it necessary for the decision of the case to carefully examine into and to state the practice, it is nothing to say as against that, that it was not necessary for the decision.
— William Brett, 1st Viscount Esher
More from William Brett, 1st Viscount Esher
The Court ought never to come to the conclusion that two cases in the same Court, or in Courts of co-ordinate jurisdiction, are in conflict, unless it is obliged to. I agree that if two cases are in conflict the Court must say with which …
Parties cannot by consent give to the Court a power which it would not have without it.
Working days in England are not the same as working days in foreign ports, because working days in England, by the custom and habits of the English, if not by their law, do not include Sundays.
It seems to me that whenever circumstances arise in the ordinary business of life in which, if two persons were ordinarily honest and careful, the one of them would make a promise to the other, it may properly be inferred that both of them …
Personally, I detest any attempt to bring the law into maxims. Maxims are invariably wrong, that is, they are so general and large that they always include something which is not intended to be included.
I agree that is the law, though I think it is a hard law; but we have nothing to do with the question of hardship.